Making an attempt Low-cost and Costly Grilled Cheeses + Images

• I attempted making a grilled cheese for $6 and $42 to see if costly components make a distinction.
• The flowery sandwich was extravagant, but it surely required lots of effort for lackluster outcomes. 
• Nothing beats a basic, nostalgic grilled cheese with American slices and white bread. 
• Visit Insider’s homepage for more stories.

Grilled cheese is my quintessential nostalgic consolation meals, particularly when it is made with white bread and American cheese.

However I needed to see how the basic sandwich would evaluate to an overtly extravagant model.

Learn on to see how a $6 grilled cheese stood up towards a $42 one. 

I began by fastidiously deciding on my components

The components have been wildly totally different in worth.

Paige Bennett for Insider

I went to Complete Meals and acquired a block of goat’s butter for $9.99 and a giant loaf of nation bread for $11.

I searched across the artisanal-cheese section to seek out Parmigiano-Reggiano for $20.99/pound, a cloth-bound cheddar for $28.99/pound, and an aged, alpine-style cheese on sale for $31.99/pound.

My grand whole for these components was $42.35.

Subsequent, I went to an Amazon Fresh retailer and grabbed a $1.48 loaf of store-brand white bread, a $1.99 bundle of yellow American-cheese slices, and a $2.49 tub of margarine, bringing that whole to $5.96.

I assembled each sandwiches concurrently to make sure a good comparability

The basic grilled cheese was simpler to assemble. The margarine simply glided with out ripping the delicate, delicate bread.

From there, I simply unwrapped two slices of American cheese.

After buttering the white bread, I pulled out the goat’s butter. It sliced simply, but it surely wasn’t delicate sufficient to unfold.

I added Parmesan cheese to the outside of the flamboyant sandwich.

Paige Bennett for Insider

The nation loaf additionally wasn’t presliced, so I needed to whip out my trusty bread knife to noticed off a few items.

I softened the goat butter for just a few seconds within the microwave earlier than spreading it on the recent slices. For additional extravagance, I created a Parmesan crust by grating the cheese on prime of the buttered slices. 

For the reason that bread was thick, I knew I had a greater likelihood of even meltage if I shredded the 2 inside cheeses slightly than slicing them.

The basic sandwich cooked up sooner than the flamboyant model

The American cheese melted rapidly onto the white bread.

Paige Bennett for Insider

I positioned the buttered aspect of 1 slice of white bread and one slice of nation loaf onto a preheated griddle pan.

The American cheese sat obediently on the white bread whereas I attempted to fastidiously pile the shredded cheeses on the slim slice of the nation loaf. 

The thickness of the nation loaf made the cooking time longer.

Paige Bennett for Insider

Then I topped every sandwich with its different half and lined all the things with a cloche to entice the warmth.

Unsurprisingly, the white bread was golden very quickly and the American cheese melted rapidly. 

The pricier grilled cheese took about twice as lengthy to prepare dinner as a result of the bread was so thick. However when it was able to flip, the gorgeous, golden crust made me gasp.

All grilled-cheese sandwiches are worthy, however I surprisingly most well-liked a budget model 

The sandwiches have been very totally different.

Paige Bennett for Insider

I cut up half of every sandwich with my associate, who was very happy to assist me style check.

I rapidly noticed how he felt as he devoured the basic sandwich and took only one chunk of the $42 grilled cheese.

There’s actually no beating a basic grilled cheese.

Paige Bennett for Insider

The cheaper one tasted precisely as I anticipated.

Your entire sandwich was delicate, with the slightest crispiness from the golden bread.

And also you simply cannot beat the soften issue of American cheese. 

The nation loaf was just a bit too thick and crunchy for me.

Paige Bennett for Insider

I liked the costly grilled cheese in numerous methods, however I most well-liked the $6 model.

The expensive sandwich was so giant and crusty that it was difficult to chunk into. The Parmesan crust was audibly crispy and scrumptious, but it surely overpowered the flavors of the inside cheeses.

The within melted OK, but it surely paled compared to the gooey American cheese.

I might completely make each once more, however the cheaper grilled cheese is a basic for a purpose.